AeroPress Recipe for Bottled Mineral Waters: 3 Shocking Truths from My Volvic vs. Evian vs. Gerolsteiner Test
Look, I get it. Obsessing over which bottled water to use for your coffee feels like the absolute peak of coffee snobbery. It’s that final 1% optimization that only people with too much time and money worry about. Right?
I thought so, too. For years. I spent a small fortune on grinders, scales, kettles, and every brewing contraption known to man (especially my beloved AeroPress). But I just used water from my tap filter and called it a day. And my coffee was... fine. Just fine.
Then I hit a wall. I bought an expensive bag of single-origin Ethiopian beans—all jasmine and lemon notes, supposedly—and it tasted like... cardboard. Flat, dull, lifeless. I blamed the beans, the roast, my grinder, my recipe. I never once blamed the water.
Big mistake. Huge.
Water is not the 1% optimization. Water is the 98% ingredient.
That realization sent me down a rabbit hole I’m only now crawling out of. I started testing everything. And to answer the question that plagues so many new coffee nerds staring at the grocery store aisle: Does expensive mineral water like Volvic, Evian, or Gerolsteiner actually make a better cup of coffee?
I bought all three. I dusted off my AeroPress. And the results weren't just "different"—they were shocking. One was great. One was disappointing. And one was an expensive, undrinkable catastrophe.
So, grab a cup (made with... well, we'll see) and let's dive in. This isn't just theory; this is a practical guide to stop wasting money and start making genuinely better coffee. Today.
Why Water Chemistry is the Secret Boss of Coffee Brewing
Before we brew, we need to understand why this matters. You can have the world's best beans and a $1,000 grinder, but if your water is fighting you, you've already lost. Coffee extraction is just chemistry. The water is a solvent, and the "stuff" dissolved in it dictates how that solvent behaves.
There are three main characters in this story:
1. Total Dissolved Solids (TDS)
This is just a measure of how much mineral "stuff" is in your water, measured in parts per million (ppm) or mg/L (they're basically the same).
- Distilled Water (0 TDS): You'd think "pure" is good, right? Wrong. It's an aggressive solvent. It has no minerals, so it rips everything out of the coffee grounds, including nasty, bitter compounds. It also lacks the minerals needed to bond with flavor. The result is a cup that's simultaneously harsh, sour, and hollow.
- Liquid Rock (High TDS): This is water that's already "full" of minerals. It's a lazy solvent. It doesn't have much "room" left to dissolve the good stuff (sugars, acids) from your coffee. The result is a dull, flat, weak, and "chalky" cup.
The Specialty Coffee Association (SCA) sets an ideal target of 75-250 mg/L TDS. This is the "Goldilocks" zone.
2. Magnesium & Calcium (The "Hardness")
These are the flavor-grabbers. Think of them as little taxis. As the water flows past the coffee grounds, these minerals jump out, grab the delicious flavor compounds (esters, aldehydes), and carry them into your cup.
- Magnesium is particularly good at grabbing onto the bright, fruity, floral compounds.
- Calcium tends to enhance the heavier, creamier, chocolatey notes.
You need these. Without them, the flavor taxis never show up, and all the good stuff stays locked in the grounds.
3. Bicarbonate (The "Buffer")
This is the most important one. This is the villain of our story. Bicarbonate (or "alkalinity") is a buffer, which means its job is to neutralize acid.
What's the best part of a high-quality, light-roast coffee? The acidity! That bright, sparkling, lemony, berry-like note is what you pay for.
When you pour water with high bicarbonate content onto those grounds, the bicarbonate immediately attacks and obliterates that acidity. It's like squeezing a whole lemon into a glass of baking soda. All that vibrant flavor is neutralized before it even has a chance to reach your cup. All you're left with is the dull, bitter, "roasty" background noise.
The Contenders: A Tale of Three Bottles
Now, let's look at our three contenders with this new chemical knowledge. I dug up the official water analysis reports for each (all data is approximate).
The Profile: Volvic Natural Spring Water
- Origin: French Volcanic Spring
- TDS: ~130 mg/L
- Calcium: ~12 mg/L
- Magnesium: ~8 mg/L
- Bicarbonate: ~74 mg/L
My Analysis: This looks... really good. The TDS (130) is right in the SCA's sweet spot (75-250). The hardness (Calcium + Magnesium) is a little low, but it's there. The bicarbonate (74) is on the high end of the SCA ideal (which is ~40 mg/L) but still reasonable. This should produce a clean, balanced cup.
The Profile: Evian Natural Spring Water
- Origin: French Alps
- TDS: ~345 mg/L
- Calcium: ~80 mg/L
- Magnesium: ~26 mg/L
- Bicarbonate: ~360 mg/L
My Analysis: Uh oh. Red flags. The TDS (345) is way over the SCA limit. The hardness minerals (80 Ca, 26 Mg) are actually pretty good. But look at that bicarbonate: 360 mg/L! That's almost 10x the ideal amount. This is an "acid-killer." I predict this will produce a very flat, dull, and chalky cup. It's just too "hard" and buffered.
The Profile: Gerolsteiner Naturell (Still)
(Important Note: I'm using their still water, "Naturell," not the famous sparkling "Sprudel." Never brew coffee with carbonated water. It will create a foamy, under-extracted mess.)
- Origin: German Volcanic Eifel
- TDS: ~800+ mg/L (This varies, but it's high)
- Calcium: ~125 mg/L
- Magnesium: ~40 mg/L
- Bicarbonate: ~550+ mg/L
My Analysis: My god. This isn't water; it's liquid rock. The TDS is astronomical. The bicarbonate level is off the charts. This water is "full." It has no desire to dissolve anything from your coffee. And any acid that does escape will be instantly murdered by the 550+ mg/L of buffer. I am... not optimistic about this one.
The Experiment: My AeroPress Recipe & The Head-to-Head Test
You can't just test water; you have to have a consistent framework. Here's what I used.
The Control Variables
- Brewer: AeroPress (Inverted Method)
- Coffee: A bright, washed Ethiopian Yirgacheffe (This is key. I need a coffee with high, delicate acidity to see how the water affects it).
- Grind: Medium-Fine (like table salt).
- Dose: 15 grams of coffee.
- Water Temp: 201°F / 94°C (I heated each water type to this exact temp).
- Water Dose: 240 grams (or 240ml).
My Standard AeroPress Recipe for Bottled Mineral Waters Test
- Set up the AeroPress in the inverted (upside-down) position on a scale.
- Add 15g of medium-fine coffee grounds. Tare the scale.
- Start a timer. Add 50g of the 201°F water, ensuring all grounds are wet. Let it "bloom" for 30 seconds.
- After 30 seconds, pour the remaining 190g of water (up to 240g total).
- Gently stir once or twice. Place the filter cap (with a rinsed paper filter) on top.
- At 1 minute 45 seconds, carefully flip the entire assembly onto a sturdy mug.
- Immediately begin to press, gently and steadily. This should take about 30 seconds.
- Stop pressing when you hear a slight hiss. Total brew time: ~2 minutes 15 seconds.
I cleaned the brewer and grinder meticulously between each test. I tasted them side-by-side. The differences were not subtle.
Tasting Notes: Volvic
Aroma: Bright, floral, hints of lemon.
Taste: Success! This is what the coffee is supposed to taste like. The lemon and jasmine notes were clear and vibrant. The body was a little thinner than I'm used to (probably due to the lowish Mg/Ca), but the acidity was balanced and sweet. It was a genuinely delicious, clean, and transparent cup of coffee.
Verdict: 9/10. A massive success. This water gets out of the way and lets the coffee shine.
Tasting Notes: Evian
Aroma: Muted. Almost... dusty? The floral notes were gone.
Taste: Ugh. Where did my coffee go? The acidity was completely gone. Obliterated. It didn't taste lemony; it just tasted vaguely "roasty." It was flat, dull, and heavy. The worst part was the finish: a distinct, unpleasant, chalky feeling on my tongue, like I'd just chewed an antacid. The high calcium and bicarbonate completely bulldozed the delicate flavors.
Verdict: 3/10. Drinkable, but a total waste of expensive coffee. It actively makes the coffee worse.
Tasting Notes: Gerolsteiner Naturell
Aroma: Nothing. Seriously, nothing but a faint, weird mineral smell.
Taste: I actually grimaced. This was an abomination. It was salty. The first note was a bizarre, savory, saline taste. All coffee flavor was gone, replaced by a flat, heavy, bitter, and salty profile. It was like someone filtered coffee through a block of limestone and then added a pinch of salt. It was completely, utterly undrinkable. I poured it out.
Verdict: 0/10. Do not do this. Ever. This is how you ruin a perfectly good bag of beans.
The Verdict: The Best Bottled Mineral Water for Your AeroPress
The results are overwhelmingly clear. This isn't a matter of "preference." This is a matter of chemistry.
🏆 The Clear Winner: Volvic
If you are stuck somewhere and must buy bottled water for your good coffee, Volvic is the one to get. Its chemical profile (TDS ~130, Bicarbonate ~74) is the closest of the three to the SCA ideal. It allows the coffee's natural acidity and sweetness to shine through, producing a clean and transparent cup.
The Disappointment: Evian
Evian is a terrible choice for specialty coffee. Its sky-high bicarbonate content (360 mg/L) acts like a chemical blanket, smothering all the delicate, bright flavors that make coffee interesting. It produces a dull, chalky, and flat brew. Save it for hydration, not extraction.
The Coffee Killer: Gerolsteiner Naturell
I cannot be more clear: do not ever brew coffee with Gerolsteiner. It is so full of minerals (TDS 800+, Bicarb 550+) that it actively ruins the coffee, rendering it a salty, bitter, flat mess. It is chemically incapable of producing a good extraction. This is a $5 bottle of water that will make your $20 bag of coffee taste like 25-cent gas station sludge.
Infographic: How Water Chemistry Hijacks Your Coffee Flavor
To visualize why this happens, here's a simple breakdown of what's happening in your cup.
Beyond the Big Three: The "Real" Pro-Level Water Solution
Okay, so Volvic is a good emergency option. But buying plastic bottles of French water isn't sustainable or cheap. So, what do you really do?
You have two great options.
Option 1: The "Easy Button" (Third Wave Water)
This is my personal favorite. You buy packets of minerals designed specifically for coffee. You buy a gallon of distilled water (which is 0 TDS) from the grocery store, and you dump one packet in. Shake it up.
That's it. You now have one gallon of perfectly designed coffee water that matches the SCA specification. It has the right amount of Magnesium and Calcium for flavor, and just enough buffer to balance the cup without flattening it. It's foolproof and consistent every single time.
Option 2: The "Budget DIY" (Filter + Remineralize)
This is for the true nerds.
- Buy a ZeroWater filter pitcher. Unlike a Brita (which only removes some stuff), a ZeroWater filter removes everything, bringing your tap water down to 0 TDS (just like distilled).
- Buy two ingredients: Epsom salt (Magnesium Sulfate) and Baking Soda (Sodium Bicarbonate).
- Make your own mineral concentrate. You can find dozens of recipes online (like the "Barista Hustle" water recipe), but a simple one involves dissolving small, precise amounts of these two ingredients into a small bottle of your 0-TDS water.
- Add a tiny bit of this concentrate to your gallon of ZeroWater, and boom: you've made perfect coffee water for pennies.
This method takes more effort, but it's the cheapest and most sustainable way to get cafe-quality water at home, every single day.
Trusted Resources for Going Deeper
Don't just take my word for it. The science of water for coffee is deep and well-documented. If you want to fall down the rabbit hole yourself, here are the best places to start.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
1. What is the best bottled water for an AeroPress?
Based on my test, Volvic is the best choice among the three most common premium brands. Its moderate TDS (~130 mg/L) and reasonable bicarbonate level (~74 mg/L) are closest to the SCA ideal, allowing the coffee's natural acidity and flavor to shine. Other "soft" spring waters with a TDS between 75-200 mg/L are also good candidates.
2. Why does Evian taste bad with coffee?
Evian tastes bad with coffee because of its extremely high bicarbonate (alkalinity) content, which is around 360 mg/L. This high level of buffer neutralizes all the delicate, bright acids in the coffee, resulting in a cup that tastes flat, dull, and heavy. It also has a high calcium content, which can leave a chalky aftertaste.
3. Can I use sparkling water like Gerolsteiner for coffee?
Absolutely not. First, never brew with carbonated water; the CO2 gas will interfere wildly with extraction and create a foamy mess. Second, even the still version (Gerolsteiner Naturell) is a terrible choice, with over 800 mg/L TDS and 550+ mg/L bicarbonate. It is chemically guaranteed to produce a flat, salty, and bitter cup. See my tasting notes here.
4. Is distilled water (0 TDS) good for coffee?
No. Distilled water is "empty" and has no mineral content (like magnesium and calcium) to help extract flavor. It's also an aggressive solvent that can over-extract bitter compounds, leading to a cup that is harsh, sour, and hollow-tasting. You need some minerals for good extraction.
5. Is Brita filtered water good for coffee?
It's better than very hard tap water, but it's not ideal. A Brita filter primarily removes chlorine and some hardness, but it doesn't give you a consistent, optimized mineral profile. It's a "good enough" solution, but if your tap water is very hard, a Brita won't remove enough bicarbonate to stop it from dulling your coffee.
6. How do I make my own coffee water at home?
The easiest way is to buy distilled water (or use water from a ZeroWater filter) and add a pre-made mineral packet, like Third Wave Water. The more advanced (but cheaper) way is to create your own mineral concentrate using Epsom salt (for magnesium) and baking soda (for bicarbonate). Check out the DIY water section.
7. Does water really matter more than my grinder or beans?
They are all critical parts of a system. But water is the foundation. You can have the best beans and grinder in the world, but bad water (like Evian or Gerolsteiner) will guarantee you a bad cup. Good water (like Volvic or DIY water) unlocks the potential of your good beans and grinder. It's the most overlooked and most impactful variable.
Final Thoughts: Stop Ignoring the Other 98%
My little experiment was a massive wake-up call. I went in a skeptic and came out a convert. Water is not a small detail; it is the main event.
We obsess over grind size, brew time, and bean origin, but we blindly trust the primary ingredient, which makes up 98% of the final drink. My test proved that the wrong water doesn't just make "slightly worse" coffee—it actively destroys it. Evian and Gerolsteiner, two premium, expensive brands, made one of my favorite coffees taste like chalky sludge.
The good news? The fix is easy.
If you're on the road or in a pinch, buy Volvic. It's a solid, reliable choice that will let your coffee be itself.
But if you're at home? Stop guessing. Take control of the 98%. Buy a gallon of distilled water and a box of Third Wave Water packets. Or get a ZeroWater filter and mix your own minerals.
I promise you, the first time you taste that bright, acidic Ethiopian bean brewed with water that isn't fighting it, you'll have the same "aha" moment I did. It's the single biggest, cheapest upgrade you can make to your coffee game. Stop brewing with "liquid rock" and start brewing with intention.
AeroPress recipe for bottled mineral waters, best water for coffee, Volvic vs Evian coffee, water TDS for AeroPress, Gerolsteiner coffee test
